Comment by Peter Siecienski on February 19, 2011 at 8:52pm
I feel like it would have to be right in front of me for me to consider it my problem. I would help the child a few streets away and probably a city away because i know I am the only one who could help it and that would tug at my conscience until I did, but unless someone was going around in my face with a collection bin, I probably wouldn't go out of my way to give them my money. I know it's a little heartless, but I rarely even think about negative things unless they're standing in front of me and that classic individualistic thinking that someone else should do it instead of me is always at the back of my mind. I can't even get myself to work out or do my homework, It's really hard to get me to help someone else if I don't even know who they are.
Comment by ryan edge on February 20, 2011 at 2:04am
Comment by ryan edge on February 20, 2011 at 2:17am

Does altruism really exist? To understand this question, you have to look at both extremes. 1st, if the kid is at your doorstep, and you help him out, the chances are high that this 'altruistic' act, will end up helping you out.. The kid owes you, and it would be a bigger burden to not let him live then it would to help him out.

Now, a kid on the other side of the planet, that you will likely never see. If you do send the money, you will likely never see any benefit over the coarse of your lifetime. This kid will likely never no your name, and never help you out down the road..

So.. the likeliness for social payback from someone kinda diminishes the further away the kid gets from you..

This would make sense evolutionarily..

Just my 2 cents.

Comment by Dean Leysen on February 20, 2011 at 9:16am

Peter: yeah, I think that's how it is for almost everyone. It's a very honest answer :)

 

Ryan: I actually think it's not about the kid owing you, but simply about soothing our conscience. It's harder for us to let a child die in front of us than to let it live, because it makes us feel worse. That's not a bad thing either if you ask me, it means that we are naturally altruistic, as long as we are sufficiently aware of and connected to the problem. But the awareness and connection are often lacking. :)

Comment by Charlene Schepens on February 20, 2011 at 9:47am

If the child is on my doorstep or a few blocks away i would help the child, but if i'm not confronted with him/her probably not.

I'd probably addopt it to, i really wanna addopt a child. But we probbably wont get one cause we're too young and we're not "wealthy" enough, we just get arround.

Comment by ryan edge on February 20, 2011 at 9:58am

Yea, I agree. Also for conscience to make sense evolutionarily, it would make sense if it was somehow advantageous to help those in need that have a chance of paying us back.

In the direct sense, yes it's because of how you feel.

But how you feel may be for selfish reasons.

Comment by Dean Leysen on February 21, 2011 at 8:03am

Really cool comments <3

Comment by Daniel Johnson on February 24, 2011 at 6:53am
Well done

Comment

You need to be a member of I Power to add comments!

Join I Power

Latest Activity

Minsc replied to jonas's discussion FEMINISM
"Society is far more accepting when men are shallow. Girls tend to have higher expectations to live up to. I personally like the Lisa & Bart Simpson analogy. Boys will be boys, so excuse them for acting like idiots or animals.   In the…"
10 minutes ago
jonas replied to jonas's discussion FEMINISM
"GOOD POINT, VERY GOOD POINT. Women just need to go for the men they find handsome, and stop pretending they are not shallow. ITS OK TO BE SHALLOW. PERFECTLY FINE. Youre not causing global warming cause you chose a handsome guy over all the others…"
1 hour ago
Jon posted a status
"spooky halloween everybodyyyy"
8 hours ago
jonas posted a status
10 hours ago
jonas replied to jonas's discussion FEMINISM
"notice the only one giving comments are black and hispanic man, Coincidence?"
yesterday
Minsc replied to jonas's discussion FEMINISM
"I was surprised you weren't in the video, until I got to 1:20. ;)   Joke's aside, I wouldn't fret too hard about this video. There's NOTHING wrong with finding a woman attractive and trying to pick her up. None of these men…"
Thursday
jonas replied to jonas's discussion FEMINISM
"A penny for your thots?"
Thursday
jonas posted a discussion

FEMINISM

a penny for your…See More
Thursday
Minsc posted a discussion

Is ATHEISM in Decline?

Have you guys ever wondered what the heck ever happened to the rise of atheism in the occident? I remember just a few years ago, it was impossible to go about your day without feeling the rising want for liberal secularism. Everyone was talking…See More
Wednesday
Minsc replied to Jon's discussion Richard Mosse: The Impossible Image
"Inspirational. "
Tuesday
Jon posted a discussion
Tuesday
jonas posted a status
Tuesday

© 2014   Created by Reese Leysen.

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service